The Law Association of New Zealand’s Criminal Law Committee has made a submission opposing the Summary Offences (Move-on-Orders) Amendment Bill in its current form.
The Bill would give police power to issue orders requiring a person to leave a public place and remain away for up to 24 hours. Breaching an order carries up to three months’ imprisonment or a $2,000 fine.
The Committee’s central objection is that the Bill enables coercive police intervention against people who have not committed a criminal offence. Police powers that interfere with personal liberty in the absence of any offending require clear justification. On several grounds, the Committee is not persuaded the Bill provides that justification.
The Law Association submission says the grounds for issuing an order are too broad. The Bill allows orders for “disruptive” behaviour that falls below the existing statutory threshold for disorderly behaviour under the Summary Offences Act 1981. Several other grounds raise concerns under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990, particularly around freedom of expression and freedom of movement.
The Committee is particularly critical of provisions making begging and rough sleeping standalone grounds for issuing an order. These risk penalising poverty and homelessness rather than harmful conduct. The submission references Ministry of Housing and Urban Development data showing at least 112,500 New Zealanders were severely housing deprived at the 2023 Census, including nearly 5,000 living without shelter. The Committee also flags potential tension with New Zealand’s obligations under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.
The Bill sets no cap on how far a person can be ordered to move and contains no requirement that any distance imposed be reasonable or proportionate. The Committee recommends this be remedied if the Bill proceeds.
On enforcement, the Committee recommends raising the evidentiary threshold from “reasonable grounds to suspect” to “reasonable grounds to believe.” It also argues that criminal liability for breach should require conduct beyond mere presence in the area, and that a $2,000 fine is disproportionate given the profile of those most likely to be subject to the regime.

